Best Luxury Hotel In Whistler: Four Seasons Vs Fairmont Chateau Whistler

Tips : Accommodation

The two best luxury hotels in Whistler are Four Seasons Whistler and Fairmont Chateau Whistler. Whether you are staying in winter for skiing or in the summer to take in the mountain air and bike or hike outdoors, whether you are travelling with your family or on a romantic couples break, you need to know which luxury hotel is the best: Four Seasons Whistler Vs Fairmont Chateau Whistler.

Whistler is conveniently located just an hour and a half away from the international destination of Vancouver. I have been fortunate enough to stay in both of these luxury hotels on numerous occasions and you cannot go wrong with either hotel. They both offer a five-star experience and are both nestled at the base of Whistler Blackcomb ski resort, framed by evergreen forests.

Both have great spas, warm outdoor pools, luxury rooms and excellent restaurants and bars. The Fairmont Chateau Whistler has the advantage of the Gold club level but overall, we feel the Four Seasons has the edge on luxury. The decor is beautiful, the bar and restaurant are atmospheric and romantic. They are superb with kids with lots of clubs and amenities. Four Seasons Whistler ticks all the boxes and is our number one choice.

Below we review each hotel in detail, considering the most important features, so that you know what you are getting whichever property you choose. We summarise which hotel feature is best so that you can make a quick decision. To get the cheapest possible deal and offers as well as free perks at both these hotels, book via our luxury travel concierge because we offer great extras like free breakfast and free room upgrades at no extra cost.

Get To Four Seasons Whistler

Fly into Vancouver International Airport and Four Seasons Resort Whistler is around a 2-hour transfer by car from Vancouver. Both hotels are just 15 minutes’ walk away from Whistler Upper Village which has coffee shops like Starbucks, bars, restaurants and array of shops. The walk is through a terribly pretty tree-filled area with a rushing mountain stream running through the centre. If you prefer, a free Four Seasons or Fairmont shuttle will pick you up and drop you off.

Best Time To Visit

Ski in the winter or enjoy the wilds of the mountains in the summer sunshine. Golf, mountain biking, hiking are all popular, or you can just relax in the spa and pool if you prefer.

Best For Rooms?

The best hotel option in Whistler for rooms has to be the Four Seasons Whistler. The rooms are stunning and have been recently renovated (see picture above) with a newly-updated take on the classic mountain lodge. After renovations that began in the spring of 2019, the Resort is debuting the property’s 273 rooms and suites in anticipation of the 2019/2020 ski season.

Nodding to the mountain’s globetrotting guests, Four Seasons Resort Whistler blends modern interiors with alpine style. Rooms combine elements of the classic lodge, paying homage to the nostalgia of winter chalets while looking forward to new memories to be made.

Inside, the sweeping updates include all new furnishings, fixtures and bespoke additions in guest rooms and suites. Clean, mid-century-inspired furnishings are featured prominently. Sleek, iron frame leather chairs and ashwood credenzas are contrasted with warm, raw-edged coffee tables. Foregoing more traditional bed frames, beds are complemented with plush wallcovering in a rustic yet refined woven textile.

Each room at Four Seasons Resort Whistler features a balcony where guests can seize every moment of the outdoors. Inside, the view is highlighted with expansive windows opening up to forest-lined mountain vistas, a view that can be taken in perched on the window seats in each room.

This stunning setting is luxuriated through unfussy details such as floating brass bedside light fixtures and sculptural ceiling light features, allowing the grandeur of the mountains to be centre stage. Modern granite fireplaces in every room at Four Seasons Resort Whistler mean guests can cosy-up fireside long after the sun goes down.

In contrast, the Fairmont Chateau Whistler has been concentrating on renovating its Suites, with the installation of fireplaces (perfect for those cozy winter months), modern spa bathrooms with soaker tub, and updated modern alpine decor, plus a generous built-in wet bar in the larger suites.

The rooms at the Fairmont Chateau Whistler are less impressive. Most have decent sized windows but few are floor to ceiling. The majority of rooms do not have balconies which is a real disadvantage. After all, there is nothing like swinging open your balcony doors to take in the summer air, or stepping out barefoot onto a balcony covered in snow, as the flakes are falling, only to return immediately to the warmth of your room so you can cosy up at your own private fireplace.

You can do this at the Four Seasons, whichever room you choose, but at the Fairmont Chateau, rooms are more generic mid-range 5 Star, and although very pleasant, they are not special in the same way. There is no balcony in most of the rooms and the ones with a balcony only offer Romeo and Juliette style, so you can’t step out or sit out. Only the suites offer fireplaces in the rooms and the size of the base room is 37m2 compared to the base “Premier Room” at the Four Seasons which is 53.8 (m2) 580 (sq.ft.). This lowest category room at the Four Seasons also features both a fireplace and a balcony.

I personally prefer the look of the Four Seasons rooms vs Fairmont Chateau Whistler. Four Seasons rooms feel like a mountain chalet, whereas the Fairmont rooms feel more generic. If you close the curtains, you could be anywhere.

Finally, the base “Premier Rooms” at the Four Seasons are great, large with almost all of the mod cons of the other rooms in this hotel. The standard rooms at the Fairmont face backwards, towards the car park rather than over the pool and the slopes. While they remain luxury rooms, they are nothing special and if you are a luxury traveller, you may be disappointed by what you get.

Best For In Room Amenities

The Fairmont offers small 40 mL bottles of Le Labo Rose 31 bath amenities which is standard for the Fairmont brand and there is no shelf in the shower for storing them. These amenities smell nice but are not my favourites. The Four Seasons offers 50 mL sized bottles of L’Occitane products which is one of my favourite amenity brands. You get more and they smell nicer at the Four Seasons.

The Fairmont offers a Keurig coffee machine and the Four Seasons has Nespresso machines which I also think are better. So for Amenities, the Four Seasons wins vs Fairmont Chateau Whistler on both counts.

Best For Sleep

Four Seasons hotel beds are fabulous across the brand and almost guarantee a good night’s sleep. Book a room facing the mountains and forest and you will not find a quieter hotel room in the world. Four Seasons wins!

Best For Location

This Four Seasons Whistler is just a short walk from the Fairmont Chateau Whistler. Both hotels are located in the Upper Village at the base of Blackcomb mountain and about a 10-15 walk from the main village along a windy path through a small thicket of pine trees and over a gushing mountain river. The walk is lovely, well lit and feels safe and brings you out into the centre of Whistler village with all its shops (clothes shops, bars, Starbucks (x2) Supermarket, fast food places etc). There is nothing to differentiate between the Four Seasons Vs Fairmont Chateau Whistler when judged by the walk into Whistler Village centre.

Best Fot Getting To Ski Slopes

The Fairmont is located at the base of Blackcomb Mountain by the Wizard Express ski lift. This means you walk out of the hotel and onto the slopes. They have a ski concierge room to store your skis/boards/boots overnight so you don’t have to carry everything back to the hotel. In this ski concierge room, there is sometimes hot chocolate available but it often seems to run out.

The Four Seasons is about a 5-minute walk away from the base of Blackcomb Mountain, which is a real pain in ski boots. Instead of walking, you will probably take the very regular Four Seasons complimentary shuttle from the entrance of the hotel to the entrance of the ski room. Their heated and stylish Four Seasons ski room has complimentary hot chocolate cookies and apple cider and boot heaters, along with a member of staff to help you store your skis and boots. From the ski room, you step straight onto the slopes.

While the Four Seasons ski room is super nice and stylish, the fact you have to shuttle to the slopes is less convenient so the Fairmont Chateau Whistler is marginally better for getting to the slopes.

Conversely, if you are worried about getting your boots on, and carrying your skis, the Four Seasons ski concierge staff are amazing and will do everything for you, from helping you to get your boots on and off to carrying your skis out to the snow.

The concierge even delivers your skis from your room or car, to the ski room and dries them and heats your boots up before you put them on again! They offer is true ski luxury.

As the short minibus ride is no hassle and the staff and free snacks in the Four Seasons ski concierge are so much better, the Four Seasons makes it easier to get out onto the slopes than the Fairmont and so the Four Seasons wins on this front too.

Best Pool

I love a hotel pool. There is little better than swimming in a warm pool or sitting in a hot tub with snow falling onto your hair. The pool at both of these hotels are heated. In the winter, both are so warm that the steam rises up from the pool as the snow falls, so you will be swimming through a cloud of warmth as the warm humid air from the pool hits the cold mountain air.

The Fairmont pool is much larger vs the Four Seasons and although it has an indoor and outdoor section, it feels more traditional and lacks the boutique feel and interesting design of the pool at the Four Seasons.

The Four Seasons pool is fully heated all year long and offers panoramic vistas of Whistler and the Blackcomb Mountains. The spacious pool deck features chaise loungers and patio tables along with chairs for those looking to dine poolside. In the winter you will find plenty of fresh towels and there is a poolside service.

I love that the Four Seasons the pool deck is heated (underfloor) too, so you don’t have to run from the indoors to the pool like an idiot to avoid frozen toes (this also avoids any icy slippiness too). There are also three therapeutic hot spring-style whirlpools along with a fully equipped gym which comes complete with personal trainers.

In the summer you get all mod cons that typify and Four Seasons pool including Sunglasses cleaning, daily treats, complimentary sunscreen and aloe gel, complimentary amenity every hour, Evian spritz, cold towels and cooling cucumber eye slices.

Best For Families With Kids

Four Seasons Whistler is extremely kid-friendly (and is also pet-friendly in certain rooms). Four Seasons hotels are always a brilliant choice if you are travelling with children. The restaurants at the Four Seasons Whistler have kids and teen menus. Rooms offer children’s bathrobes and slippers and babysitting services. There is also a children’s programme offering evening entertainment. The resort offers fantastic winter and summer programmes providing loads to do for kids of all ages.

The most exclusive accommodation at the Four Seasons is the Private Residences. Perfect for family holidays in Whistler. Set apart from the main hotel, the Residences are beautifully designed and decorated, with views of the surrounding forest, valley or mountains from private furnished terraces accessed by enormous French windows. They feature kitchens, spacious living areas, state-of-the-art home entertainment systems and pampering bathrooms with deep-soak tubs.

So the Four Seasons Whistler is undoubtedly the best choice for families with children (and dogs and cats!).

Best Restaurant And Bar

Four Seasons has a daily free wine tasting, and if that doesn’t win you over, you can also enjoy excellent food at this Four Seasons in a more atmospheric setting than the Fairmont.

The Four Seasons Whistler main restaurant is Fifty Two 80 Bistro. Open for breakfast, lunch and dinner, guests can enjoy the fabulous views of the surrounding mountains. The Four Seasons Sidecut is a sleek steakhouse featuring an open fireplace and a 1,800-degree infrared grill that cooks Canadian prime beef to juicy perfection. Right outside is the heated patio, which has its own fireplace where kids (and kids at heart) roast marshmallows after dinner. For après cocktails and live music, guests stop at the swanky Fifty Two 80 lounge.

The Fairmont also has lounges and restaurants but the overall feel is less intimate and more like a large lobby lounge and traditional hotel restaurant(s). While the Fairmont restaurants and bars are very good, those at the Four Seasons are great, so in the Four Seasons vs Fairmont battle, the Four Seasons once again wins.

Best Club Lounge

Only the Fairmont offers a club lounge which you get access to by booking their Gold rooms. The Fairmont Chateau Whistler Gold floor accommodations offer jetted tubs and gas fireplaces in every room along with upgraded hotel amenities and Bose sound systems.

The Fairmont Gold accommodations are located on the 9-12th Floor with some Fairmont Gold rooms on the 8th floor. Privileges include:
Private check-in and check-out
Exclusive Fairmont Gold Lounge for Fairmont Gold guests
Deluxe Continental Breakfast in the Fairmont Gold Lounge
All day coffee & tea service in the Fairmont Gold Lounge
Afternoon canapés & honour bar in the Fairmont Gold Lounge
Complimentary newspapers and personalized wake-up calls
Fairmont Gold privileges include exclusive access to the Fairmont Gold Lounge. Relax fireside while enjoying complimentary Deluxe Continental Breakfast, local newspapers, magazines, catching up on email with our complimentary laptop computer or simply unwinding after a day on Whistler Mountain.

As Four Seasons does not have a club lounge, the Fairmont wins on for best executive lounge in Whistler.

Best Deals?

I reviewed the best way to get deals and special offers at Four Seasons Whistler separately, the key is to book your next Four Seasons stay via our luxury travel concierge and we can give you FREE loyalty-style benefits, room upgrades and perks, at the same cheapest rates.

The same goes for the Fairmont Chateau Whistler. Book your next Fairmont stay via our luxury travel concierge and we can give you FREE loyalty-style benefits. Our free benefits at Fairmont Chateau Whistler are very similar to those offered at the Four Seasons and include; upgrade on arrival, subject to availability, daily full breakfast, for up to two guests per bedroom served in the restaurant, welcome amenity, $100 USD equivalent Food & Beverage credit to be utilized during stay (not combinable, no cash value if not redeemed in full), early check-in/late check-out subject to availability, complimentary Wi-Fi.

The Best Overall: Four Seasons Vs Fairmont Chateau Whistler

Four Seasons Resort Whistler is best, hands down. The only factor where the Fairmont comes close is their Gold Level with their club lounge. This Gold level offers better than average accommodation within the Fairmont and club lounge access. On more or less every other factor, Four Seasons Whistler wins as it is is a brilliant ski hotel for both couples and families.

Other luxury hotel options include the two Pan Pacific hotels, Pan Pacific Whistler Village Centre and Pan Pacific Whistler Mountainside, which are on a similar level to the Fairmont and a step below the Four Seasons, followed by the Delta Marriott Whistler Village, The Blackcomb Lodge, Summit Lodge Boutique Hotel and The Listel Hotel Whistler.

Features

Hotel Review: Four Seasons Whistler, Canada

In "Accommodation"

We have reviewed the best Four Seasons hotels in North America, which includes the stunning Four Seasons Whistler in the rocky mountains in Canada. The Four Seasons Whistler is also one of the best Four Seasons Ski Resorts in the… Read More.

Find out which hotels I consider to be the best Four Seasons hotels in the world.

Disclosure: Unless otherwise stated reviews are sponsored by the proprietor or brand being appraised. All opinions remain our own & are in no way influenced.