United Economy Vs Premium Economy: Is It Worth Upgrading?

Tips : Transport

When flying on United Airlines, is it worth paying to upgrade to Premium Economy versus Economy seats on long-haul flights?

United Airlines is one of the best Premium Economy airlines in the world with exclusive and spacious cabins. Seats are wider but the seat recline is poor compared to other Premium Economy products. Legroom is increased and you also have your own adjustable footrests. You also get soft goods (pillow & blanket), premium food, and inflight amenities. When compared to other international carriers United’s new Premium Economy is better than Air France and is similar if not slightly better than Lufthansa.

The launch of United’s new Premium Plus class was one of the best bits of aviation news for airline travelers in 2019. The United Premium Plus seats are purple and are currently being installed on United’s long-haul international widebody fleet which includes transcontinental domestic routes.

The new seats will be present on most 777s and all their brand new 787-10 aircraft. Premium Plus is currently offered on trans-Atlantic, trans-Pacific, and South American routes. These routes include: Newark to Hong Kong, Mumbai, Tokyo, Brussels, Paris, Frankfurt, Dublin, Barcelona, and Tel Aviv; San Francisco to Hong Kong, Tokyo, Taipei, Frankfurt, London, Paris, Beijing, Auckland, and Tel Aviv; and Washington Dulles to Brussels, Paris and Tel Aviv. These planes with Premium Plus also have the newest Polaris Business Class.

1. Economy Vs Premium Economy: Price

If the price is your biggest factor when making the decision on which class to fly in, you should probably choose to fly Economy. After all, the entire plane will get to its destination, whichever class you are sitting in.

Having said that, particularly for overnight flights, being stuffed in a sardine-tin, with little space to move and next-to-no recline, means that sleep is difficult.

Certainly, when I have flown in Economy, if I do manage to nod off, the fact that my head then drops to one side because of the lack of seat recline, means that I almost always wake myself up.

The result is that you can feel pretty grotty after an Economy flight when you get to your destination. This means that you are potentially ruining the first day of your trip because you have not spent the extra on upgrading your flight.

So even if the price IS your biggest factor, Premium Economy can mean that you avoid wasting a day of your holiday which may ultimately be worth more than the price difference. Premium Economy is also significantly cheaper than flying in Business Class, usually 65% less expensive than a business class fare.

How much extra is Premium Economy on United? Premium Economy is typically 30%-90% more expensive than flying in Economy. Expect to pay up to double the price to fly in Premium Economy.

By comparison, Business Class can be as much as 5 times as expensive as Economy and up to 3 times as expensive as Premium Economy, putting United’s Premium Plus Premium Economy at an extremely interesting price point for most travelers.

For a better deal on Business Class flights or luxury hotels, contact our luxury travel concierge for a free quote. We offer free upgrades, free breakfasts, and free perks at hotels including Four Seasons, Hyatt, Ritz Carlton, InterContinental, and many more.

2. Economy Vs Premium Economy: Loyalty Program

In terms of loyalty programs, United operates MileagePlus Frequent Flyer Miles, its Frequent Flyer loyalty program. It is is a fairly good frequent flyer scheme. Obviously, you get more miles if you fly in Premium Economy because you are spending more money.

3. Economy Vs Premium Economy: Check-in & Hold Baggage

From dedicated check-in to priority boarding, enjoy priority treatment throughout your journey if you are flying in Premium Economy, which is a major advantage over flying Economy.

United Premium Plus customers get enhanced luggage allowance with two free checked bags per person. This is a valuable perk.

4. Economy Vs Premium Economy: Lounges

United offers excellent lounges. As with most airlines, lounge access isn’t included with a United Premium Economy ticket. You can also use your Priority Pass or pay to access to airport lounges but they won’t necessarily be the same United Airlines lounges that Business Class passengers access. There is no advantage to flying Premium Economy in this respect as neither Economy or Premium Economy passengers get access to the excellent United Business and First Class airport lounges unless they are frequent flyers and premium members of United or Star Alliance airline loyalty schemes.

5. Economy Vs Premium Economy: Toilets

Unfortunately, Premium Economy passengers share the same two lavatories with the Economy Plus section. The amenity kit you get in Premium Economy is, however, decent, with socks, toothbrush, and eyeshades. You don’t get this kit in Economy.

6. Economy Vs Premium Economy: Seat

There are only 3 rows of Premium Economy Purple seats and many less than Polaris Business Class seats. This tiny, intimate Premium Economy Cabin, means that you don’t have to fight for hand luggage space in the overhead bins and you get to board and exit the plane faster than those in Economy.

Highlights of United’s Premium Economy include their superb (IFE) in-flight entertainment and comfortable seats which you can stretch out and sleep in. The level of comfort between Economy and Premium Plus Economy is significant and larger than the difference between Economy and Economy Plus (which United still offers).

You get a large leather reclining seat with a footrest and a lot more space. The seats are set up in a 2-4-2 configuration which is 8 across compared to 10 across in Economy. You get approx 5-7 inches of extra legroom around 2 extra inches of seat width and free food and alcoholic drinks.

The seat is wider (19 inches Premium Economy versus 17 in Economy Plus), the pitch is 38” vs. 34” in Economy Plus. Their Economy seat has less than 32 inches of pitch so really is very tight and the recline is 6″ in Premium Economy vs. 4”.

The Saks Fifth Avenue pillows and blankets are the same as in Polaris. There is also more in-seat storage. The armrests between the Premium Economy seats are also wide, so your elbows have space.

For me, the extra elbow room in the Premium Economy seats enables me to work more comfortably on my laptop, making the width worth paying for.

7. Economy Vs Premium Economy: Seat Recline

The United Premium Economy seat recline is not a whole lot more than in Economy but the legrest and a footrest make up for this and there is plenty of legroom. Most Economy seats have a recline of 4-6 inches so any increase is an advantage but the lack of much extra recline is a real downside of the United Premium Economy offering.

8. Economy Vs Premium Economy: Entertainment

In Premium Economy, the monitor for entertainment is larger in Premium Economy, at 13.3-inch vs. 9 HD seatback screen, although the catalog of movies and tv is the same. United have a good library of on-demand movies and tv. You also get those noise-canceling headphones in Premium and the in-seat power and USB work. In Economy, the screens are smaller and you don’t get noise-canceling headphones.

9. Economy Vs Premium Economy: Flight Attendants

United flight attendants serving the Premium Economy cabin have more time for you than those serving in the United Airlines Economy cabin, so Premium Economy wins.

10. Economy Vs Premium Economy: Food

You get free drinks and free food in United Premium Economy. The menu offering is enhanced and the food is decent.

The food is better than Economy but not as good as Business. It is not served on plastic plates but the meal comes on one tray which ers towards Economy Class in presentation.

The food selection includes optional on-demand snacks and free drinks, including alcohol. Overall the food is much better than Economy.

Conclusion:

I would say that the United Premium Economy is a good product and worth paying the extra if you can afford it. United’s Premium Plus Premium Economy is a major improvement in terms of comfort but lacks a decent recline. Premium Economy does not offer a lie-flat bed like United’s Polaris Business Class. If you want to afford it, Business Class will always be the better choice.

But Business Class can be as much as 5 times as expensive as Economy and up to 3 times as expensive as Premium Economy, putting United’s Premium Plus Premium Economy at an extremely interesting price point for most travelers. I have flown in Premium Economy and would not hesitate to fly it again.

Below you will find my most recent flight reviews on United Airlines in Business and First Class – you can draw your own conclusions on their current and future Business Class products:

Features

Transatlantic Flight Review: United B787-9 Dreamliner Polaris Business Class

In "Reviews"

In this trip report, I review my transatlantic flight on United Airlines B787-9 Dreamliner Polaris Business Class from Paris to San Francisco. This flight took place in August 2017, from Charles De Gaulle Airport (CDG) in France to San Francisco… Read More.

Flight Review: United B777 Polaris Domestic First Class To Hawaii

In "Reviews"

I flew domestic to Hawaii in Polaris First Class on United Airlines Boeing 777-200 from San Francisco International Airport (SFO) in California to Honolulu International Airport (HNL) in August 2017. I have already detailed the best airlines to fly First… Read More.

Flight Review: United Polaris Business Class On Boeing 777-300ER

In "Reviews"

In this trip report, I review my flight in Polaris Business Class (including the new seats) on United’s Boeing 777-300ER from Hong Kong (HKG) to San Fransisco (SFO). This flight cost just over $7,000 USD one way and earned 35,130… Read More.

Flight Review: United Polaris Business Class On 787-9 Dreamliner

In "Reviews"

United launched its new Polaris Business Class in December 2016, replacing their BusinessFirst; and Polaris First replacing Global First cabins. The brand new United Polaris Pod concept, which is named after the brightest star in the Ursa Minor constellation, is… Read More.

Review: United Polaris Business Class On The Boeing 777-300ER

In "Reviews"

You can now fly the complete United Polaris Business Class experience on the Boeing 777-300ER. This is the first United aircraft to feature the United Polaris hard product; their new all-aisle access, lie-flat seat. Read More.

Flight Review: United Polaris First Class

In "Reviews"

In this trip report, I review United Polaris First Class Frankfurt to San Francisco (SFO) on a Boeing 747-400. United launched its new Polaris First Class, replacing its Global First cabins. United Polaris First will eventually be phased out and… Read More.

United P.S. B757-200 Business Class Review EWR-LAX

In "Reviews"

In this article I review the United Airline Premium Service (P.S.) or Business Class, on the B757-200 New York Newark (EWR) to Los Angeles (LAX). Read More.

Insider Photo Tour Of New United Polaris Business Class

In "Reviews"

United Airlines has launched its new United Polaris business class, which will culminate in a new fully-flat business class seat next year (read my article about the new United Polaris seat including more photos). Read More.

Note: Benefits offered correct at the time of writing but may be amended at discretion of the vendor.

Disclosure: Posts may be sponsored by the proprietor or brand being appraised. All opinions remain our own & are in no way influenced.