Is it ethical for chief executives and senior management to accept fat bonuses if they are underdelivering? Should American Airlines be embarrassed for bonusing their management even though they seem to have missed their targets?
American Airlines CEO Doug Parker clearly stated in their investor date in September 2017 that the airline would never lose money again. He argued that they would always earn in the range of $3 billion USD to $7 billion USD per year.
According to Gary from View from the Wing, they barely hit this target in 2017 and they missed it in 2018.
Parker explained that executive bonuses were determined by their ability to hit these profit figures, earning partial bonuses at $3 billion USD and more at the $5 billion USD and $7 billion USD levels. So what happened to executive bonuses when the airline failed to meet this goal for 2018? Executives received bonuses anyway.
Should American Airlines be embarrassed? Possibly, but this kind of executive bonusing is quite common in our capitalist world, sometimes regardless of executive results. In other words, American Airlines are not alone.
When he was asked about this on Thursday’s earnings call, CEO Parker said: “In 2018, you’re right on a reported basis we were slightly below $3 billion USD on a pre-tax level, but this calculation is made prior to the payments themselves of course and before profit sharing. So what you’ll see in the proxy is that while it was reported numbers below $3 billion USD in terms of the plan calculation, it was slightly above $3 billion USD. So the team got 51% of their target bonus in 2018.”
Parker argues that it’s necessary to pay bonuses to retain top executives. These top executives may leave if they are not compensated for not hitting their targets. Conversely, one could argue that if these underperforming executives left, the airline could bring in new executives who might actually hit the targets?
Two travel bloggers argue the case to fly with American Airlines and to NEVER fly on American Airlines below. They may help you decide whether to fly on AA, given the product and the management decisions. But it’s not all bad. Last week American made 5 surprising decisions to improve their flights.
American Airlines is getting worse, yet Gary, who writes travel blog View From The Wing, insists he still chooses to fly American Airlines even though he is one of their biggest critics. Read More.
Note: Posts may be sponsored by the proprietor or brand being appraised. All opinions remain our own & are in no way influenced.