Is Trump Right? Is There Too Much Technology In Our Planes?


Following the crash of the Ethiopian Boeing 737 MAX, this plane that has now been grounded around the world including in the United States. Since this decision was made, a crucial question has been raised “Is there too much technology on our planes?”

In fact, this question was raised by the President of the United States, Donald J Trump:

The decision to ground planes comes after Southwest revealed a decision to add new angle of attack indicators to its fleet, matching those American Airlines already has on its MAX jets providing additional data to cockpit crew which may avert an incident similar to what happened to Lion Air’s MAX in October. Previously, Southwest Airlines had 34 Boeing 737 MAX aircraft in service. American Airlines had 24.

The question is, is Donald Trump right? There have indeed been horrible crashes that have been caused by computer software, which pilots have been unable to overcome. These automatic features suggest that, although these systems have been tested, certain crucial scenarios were missing from the testing.

The brilliance of software is limited by the brilliance of the software programmer(s) who are human. Mistakes may be made and while an experienced pilot may know how to pull a plane out of a bad situation, new software may not be prepared for certain anomalies.

We must not forget, however, that overall, airline software has undoubtedly also prevented numerous crashes. It would be impossible to determine how many crashes have been avoided with the help of computers.

Evidence may suggest that the last two B737 plane crashes have been a result of software issues and that the pilots seemed unable to take over from the software. While the majority of airline software makes our skies safer, pilots need to remain vigilant and alert and must be able to override the software where necessary.

Captain Sully performed a miracle on the Hudson River in 2009, landing his plane and saving his passengers. Would the B737 MAX have let him take over the controls or would he have been overridden by the technology?

We need brilliant, well-trained pilots in our skies. We need our planes to embrace technology but this technology needs to be tested in every scenario. Crucially, it needs to be easier for pilots to understand and override failing technology.

Why Wasn’t The B737 Max Grounded Sooner?

IMHO, when the first Boeing B737 Max went down, they should all have been grounded. Why all B373 Max planes were not grounded at that point is most probably a decision based on economics rather than passenger safety. The cost of a second crash was paid with a terrible loss of life. I wish all these planes had been grounded after the first crash, until everyone was sure they were safe.

Fly For Free

I fly around Europe very regularly in Business Class on British Airways. If you want to fly on British Airways for free like I do, I have outlined the three best British Airways Avios air mile credit cards with a referral bonus to get you onto that plane in style as quickly as possible.

If I were flying on a domestic flight in America, for now at least, I would choose to fly on Delta with their older fleet with less surprises. If you are US based you can find out about a brilliant way to load up on a massive bonus of airline miles in this easy guide.

Get Free Benefits At Luxury Hotels

Wherever you fly to, if you want to book a hotel, use our luxury travel concierge. We offer free upgrades, free breakfasts, free hotel credit and VIP gifts at major luxury hotel brands like Four Seasons, Belmond, Ritz Carlton, InterContinental and more.

Best Rates Guaranteed

If you prefer 3 or 4-star hotels & flights, try Club1Hotels and get wholesale hotel rates that are guaranteed to be the best rates every time! If you find better, Club1Hotels will beat the rate* you find so you can’t lose! Join FREE here.

Want Another Bargain?

Take a look at our luxury travel auctions, one of the best places to pick up a travel bargain for a fraction of its actual price!

Disclosure: Our property, service and product reviews are sponsored by the proprietor or brand being appraised. All opinions remain our own and are in no way influenced by the sponsor.